(For those who are brave, can’t view PDFs, or simply adore scrolling. Reference numbers should be clickable, as should some of the table of contents.) (more…)
Woefully belated. Endnoted up the wazoo. Marked lack of cutesy.
Click here for the HTML version, or head straight to the PDF:
(Updated noon-ish PST on August 3rd with typo corrections)
I’ll see what I can do about getting this set up in blog-post form, but I really don’t have the mental capacity to work on it right now. Sorry. In the meantime, here’s the table of contents so you know what you’re getting yourself into:
SECTION 1: Reiteration and Expansion of Criticisms
- Linkage of animal protein with cancer by way of cholesterol
- Misleading association of breast cancer with lipid intake and lipid intake with animal protein
- Supposition that plasma cholesterol increases liver cancer risk
- Misrepresentation of heart-protective effects of green vegetables, and the three-variable linkage between animal protein, apolipoprotein B, and cardiovascular disease
- Biased use of unadjusted univariate correlations to confer protective benefits of plant foods but not with animal foods
- Use of a three-variable chain to connect animal foods with “Western” diseases
- Unexplored role of blood glucose, insulin, and disease
- Dismissing relevant variables
- Errors in the extrapolation of casein to all animal protein
SECTION 2: Biological Models and Cited Papers
- Breast cancer
- Liver cancer
- Energy utilization
- Affluent-poverty diseases
SECTION 3: Response to Points Raised by Campbell
- Wheat: confounded variable or legitimate concern?
- Selection of univariate correlations and confirmation bias
- Tuoli county and erroneous data
- Whole-food, plant-based diets versus whole-food diets with animal products
And before anyone gets their knickers in a knot, listen up: Every time I employed a univariate correlation, it was because Campbell had done so first, under the same circumstances. Every. Time.
Also, this is sort of a pre-final version, and there may be typos (please point them out!) or orphaned punctuation (ditto). If I make any changes, I’ll post the updated version with a note.
Now if you’ll excuse me, I’m going to spend a very, very long time not staring at the computer screen, catching up on a couple weeks’ worth of sleep, and hopefully regrowing the little chunks of my soul that died while writing this. Adieu!